How to Hire InfoSec Talent in 2025: Skills-Based Assessments That Actually Work
- Saman Nayab
- Aug 13
- 4 min read
In 2025, hiring Information Security (InfoSec) professionals is one of the toughest recruitment challenges for US companies. Cyberattacks are increasing in frequency and sophistication, compliance requirements are tightening, and the cost of a data breach can easily exceed $4 million according to IBM’s 2025 Cybersecurity Report.
The stakes are high — a single bad hire in your security team can leave your organization vulnerable. The problem? Many companies still use outdated hiring methods that focus on credentials instead of real-world skills. The solution is clear: skills-based assessments, paired with a streamlined recruiting model like flat-fee recruiting, can help you hire the right InfoSec talent faster, cheaper, and with greater confidence.
The High Stakes of InfoSec Hiring
In a world where ransomware attacks, phishing campaigns, and insider threats make headlines weekly, every security hire matters. Here’s why:
Financial Risk: The average cost of a cybersecurity breach in the US is $9.5 million in 2025, including downtime, customer loss, and regulatory penalties.
Reputation Damage: Clients, partners, and investors expect robust security. A breach can erode trust overnight.
Regulatory Pressure: GDPR, CCPA, HIPAA, and industry-specific compliance frameworks demand airtight data protection practices.
Given these stakes, hiring based solely on resumes or degrees is no longer enough. You need to see proof of performance before you hire.
Traditional recruitment often fails InfoSec hiring for three key reasons:
Over-Reliance on Resumes Many security professionals hold certifications like CISSP or CEH, but these alone don’t guarantee day-to-day problem-solving ability.
Generic Interviews Asking “Tell me about a time you…” questions without testing real technical scenarios leaves hiring managers guessing.
Slow, Reactive Processes Top InfoSec candidates are off the market in 10–15 days. Lengthy interview cycles mean losing them to competitors.
Skills-based assessments let you evaluate a candidate’s ability to handle real-world security challenges before they join your team. Instead of hiring based on what’s on paper, you hire based on proven capability.
Benefits include:
Objective Decision-Making: Reduces bias by focusing on results, not background.
Faster Hiring: Quickly identify top performers and move them through the process.
Better Retention: Candidates who can do the job from day one are more likely to succeed long-term.
What to Test: Core Skills for InfoSec Roles
Effective InfoSec skills tests go beyond multiple-choice quizzes. They should combine technical tasks with critical thinking assessments. Examples include:
Penetration Testing Simulations – Evaluate a candidate’s ability to identify and exploit vulnerabilities in a controlled environment.
Secure Coding Challenges – Test their ability to write code that follows secure development practices, identifying and patching vulnerabilities.
Incident Response Drills – Provide a simulated breach scenario and see how candidates investigate, contain, and remediate it.
Compliance & Policy Knowledge – Short case studies on GDPR, HIPAA, or ISO 27001 to gauge regulatory understanding.
Psychometric Tests – Assess traits like problem-solving, attention to detail, and risk management under pressure.
How Flat-Fee Recruiting Streamlines InfoSec Hiring
Even with the right assessment process, recruitment can be costly and slow — unless you change your hiring model.
Flat-fee recruiting means you pay one fixed price to fill the role, no matter the salary. This gives you:
Cost Control: Avoid paying 20–30% of salary in agency fees.
Transparency: Know upfront exactly what your hiring budget is.
Speed: A dedicated recruiter focused on results, not commissions.
For InfoSec roles, this model is especially valuable because salaries often exceed $150K. A flat fee can save tens of thousands of dollars per hire.
New Section: Real-World Case Study — Skills-Based InfoSec Hiring in Action
To see how this works, imagine a US fintech company looking to hire a Security Operations Center (SOC) Analyst in under 20 days.
The old way:
6+ weeks screening resumes and holding generic interviews
Multiple candidates drop out due to slow feedback
Final hire needs extra training before they can contribute
The skills-based + flat-fee way:
Define the exact technical stack (SIEM tools, IDS/IPS experience, compliance frameworks)
Use a 90-minute skills assessment combining penetration testing, log analysis, and incident response simulation
Shortlist top 3 candidates within 7 days
Make a hire in 14 days with zero agency commission markup
Result: Faster onboarding, higher capability from day one, and cost savings of $25,000 compared to a traditional agency.
Step-by-Step: Implementing Skills-Based Hiring for InfoSec Roles
Step 1: Define Role Requirements – Be specific — list the tools, frameworks, and regulatory environments your hire must know (e.g., Splunk, NIST, PCI DSS). Step 2: Select Assessment Types – Mix technical challenges, scenario-based simulations, and psychometric tests for a full skills profile. Step 3: Partner with a Flat-Fee Recruiter – Work with a recruiter who specializes in skills-based hiring for tech/security roles. Step 4: Shortlist Fast – Only advance candidates who score above your threshold. This cuts interview time and speeds up hiring. Step 5: Conduct Targeted Interviews – Focus interviews on clarifying results from assessments, not repeating them. Step 6: Onboard with Security in Mind – Have policies, tools, and processes ready so your new hire can hit the ground running.
FAQs on Hiring InfoSec Talent in 2025
Q1: What’s the average time to hire an InfoSec professional in the US?
A: In 2025, it’s around 44 days with traditional methods, but skills-based hiring can cut that to under 20 days.
Q2: Are certifications like CISSP and CEH still important?
A: Yes, they’re valuable, but they should be paired with hands-on skills assessments to confirm real-world capability.
Q3: What’s the cost advantage of flat-fee recruiting for InfoSec roles?
A: You can save between $15K–$30K per hire compared to percentage-based agency fees, especially for roles with six-figure salaries.
Q4: Can skills-based hiring work for entry-level InfoSec roles?
A: Absolutely — you can test for foundational skills, learning ability, and problem-solving even for junior candidates.
Q5: What’s the biggest hiring mistake companies make in InfoSec? A: Waiting too long to make an offer. The best candidates are gone in under two weeks.
Conclusion: Why 2025 is the Year to Rethink InfoSec Hiring
Cybersecurity risks are only getting more complex, and the talent pool isn’t getting bigger. If you want to secure the right talent, you need to move away from guesswork and toward proof-driven hiring. Skills-based assessments combined with flat-fee recruiting give you the perfect balance of speed, accuracy, and cost-effectiveness.
Ready to hire InfoSec talent without paying inflated agency fees? At Behoof, we help US businesses hire skilled InfoSec professionals quickly and affordably — without compromising on quality.
Comments